Soy and Pea Protein Built as Much Lean Mass as Whey in Beginners Lifting Weights, a Review of 5 Trials Found
Irineu Otavio Marchiori Callegari, Giovana Molina Silva, Alexandre Gabarra Oliveira
Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition October 29, 2026
What the researchers wanted to know
Do plant-based protein supplements build as much lean mass and reduce as much body fat as whey protein in adults who are starting weight training?
Why it matters
Whey, which comes from milk, is the most studied protein supplement. Many people avoid dairy or animal products and use soy or pea protein instead. Plant proteins contain less of some building blocks that muscles use, so it was unclear whether they work as well.
Whey protein is made from milk. It is rich in leucine, a protein building block that helps switch on muscle building.
Plant proteins, such as soy and pea, usually contain less leucine per gram.
Lean mass is everything in the body that is not fat. When it rises during weight training, most of the gain is muscle. It is measured most reliably with a body scan called DXA.
The researchers searched three research databases for trials that:
- compared a plant protein supplement with whey protein
- enrolled healthy adults aged 18 to 59 who were new to weight training
- measured body composition with a DXA scan
They found 5 trials with 372 people. Three tested soy, one pea and one chia. Daily supplements gave about 19 to 26 g of protein. Everyone did weight training, in most trials 3 times a week for 8 to 12 weeks. One trial lasted 9 months.
The results were combined into one overall number. The plan was registered in advance.
Plant protein and whey led to similar changes in lean mass and body fat.
- Lean mass and body fat improved with weight training in both groups.
- The overall difference in lean mass was 0.35 kg in favor of whey, too small and too uncertain to count as a real difference.
- The true difference could lie anywhere from 2.5 kg in favor of whey to 1.8 kg in favor of plant protein.
- Body fat changes were alike across the trials.
Results by protein type:
- Pea: similar gains to whey in a 12-week trial.
- Soy: similar gains to whey in two 12-week trials. In the 9-month trial, whey led to more lean mass.
- Chia: tested in one trial, where neither chia nor whey added lean mass beyond training alone.
Conclusion
Soy and pea protein supplements led to gains in lean mass similar to whey protein in adults new to weight training.
Therefore
People who avoid dairy may be able to use soy or pea protein in place of whey when they start weight training.
How much can you trust this study?
Two studies can say the same thing and deserve very different amounts of trust. LayMed scores every study out of 100 on:
- Study design
- Bias Control & Transparency
- Size and precision
- Measurement
LayMed Plus members see the Study Quality score for every study, with the reason behind each part.
Get LayMed Plus$7.99 a month or $79 a year
How far does this apply to you personally?
A study can earn a high quality score and still not apply well to you. How much its results carry over to you can change a lot depending on your sex, age, race or ethnicity, body weight, genes, hormones, blood pressure and resting heart rate, health conditions, medications, activity level, training experience, diet, sleep, smoking and drinking, job and gut bacteria.
Hover over or tap any of these to see a real study where it changed the results.
LayMed Plus members get a personal Relevance score for every study. It weighs all of these factors to estimate how well the results apply to you and your life.
Get LayMed Plus$7.99 a month or $79 a year
Important new studies, explained in plain English, sent straight to your inbox.
Almost done. Please check your email for a confirmation sent from "laymed@dr-gains.com".
Last checked against the source: November 20, 2026
Update November 20, 2026: Written to the LayMed article standard from the full published paper.
LayMed articles are plain-English summaries of published research, written for education. They are not medical advice. Always read the original study and talk to a qualified professional about your own situation.